Would you rather befriend someone because they have the same race as you or the same gender?
Here's a harder question: Would you rather vote for someone because they have the same race as you or the same gender?
A good friend was telling me the other day that an older male friend, who is married with two daughters, was stressing the importance that men should realize how they don't understand women's struggles. That, I agree with completely, although I feel it is a lost cause (I'll explain why later).
Women walk around and are always judged by their physical appearance and manners- by men and women. Sure, some men judge other men by their looks, but not in the same way that women are judged. Men would think "she's too fat" or "she has a huge rack" while they'd look at a man and think "he looks rich" or "he looks like a hick."
Complete difference.
So my problem with this is that a majority of women have bought into that and also judge other women by their clothes, make-up, hair style or even their (or lack thereof) accessories.
Women have been spoon-fed this bullshit that women who look and act a certain way are one thing and women who look and act a different way are another thing. One is good, one is bad. But no matter what, it diversifies us. It splits us. It harms us. And as a group, women aren't unified- they're broken. Therefore, as a group, we are weak. And we can not overcome sexism by being so vulnerable that we prey upon each other, while we have to watch our backs because men are preying upon us as well.
Look at the black community. There are black churches, stereotypical black food, black heroes, black cities ... and now they have Barack Obama- a potential black president.
As for the women? We don't have churches, food, heroes, cities and we sure as hell don't have a potential woman president anymore. For women to gain respect as a group, and therefore unify and strengthen itself, the power, confidence and strength must come from the inside. We must create a culture to preserve it and support it. So in order to get respect, we must first respect other women.
We can't continue to classify each other as "whore" or "bitch" or even "housewife" because those words were put there, by men, to cut us down. And now we've grabbed those sharp words and we're cutting ourselves down with them. We can't expect to gain social status if we're feeding into the male bullshit of what a woman "should be like."
Yes, I said we need to gain social status. A lot of it to be close to where men are ranked.
For those of you who are appalled and perhaps dumbfounded at that comment, let me help you out from under the rock you've been living under and let me explain that we lost the chance of having a woman president for a multitude of reasons, but a main reason is that women did not stick together. Most feminist organizations actually supported Barack, if you could believe that.
Another point to ponder is the fact that Barack is reaching to everyone of his race- he's reaching outside of political lines. Armstrong Williams, a black conservative talkshow host, said that he's willing to vote for Barack in November, which would be the first time he'd ever vote for a Democrat to be president. He will vote for him because they're both black.
If Obama has that type of power, imagine what women could have if we pulled ourselves together. Women make up the majority of the world's population, yet we are treated and we feel as though we're a minority. That's what type of mind trick men have played on us.
Women didn't come together to vote for a woman president because race stumps gender. People of race are more likely to stick together than are people of the same gender. Obviously, the country is more sexist than racist.
Ladies: no matter how many history books or feminist classes men take, they'll never understand the depreciation that women feel on a daily basis, just like how we'll never understand what it was like to be a woman 100 years ago, when it was much more unequal. We can't depend on anyone but ourselves to hoist ourselves up through the social ladder and to eventually shatter the glass ceiling.
I find it disgraceful that women put other women down. Women stab women in the backs. Women won't vote for a woman to be president. End your selfish ignorance, step out of your box and look at the big picture: we must promote women's rights.
Barack will be president because he was able to unify his race (plus many other non-black people) unlike other black politicians before him. But women are waiting for a woman who's able to do the same for our gender. Where's our hero?
Hopefully, one day, our granddaughters won't know the term "glass ceiling." They'll shockingly read in history books how it was the norm for men to be U.S. president or CEOs.
But that'll only happen if we make it happen.
The change starts with us.
Now.
Sunday, June 15, 2008
Race stumps gender
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

3 comments:
Pretty powerful post. I think the feminist organizations wanted to make a point by unifying behind Barack. Therefore they can show that they don't need a woman to be president to gain social status.
Which I'm sure we would both agree is a big miscalculation.
Women have been increasing their social status for years and that trend is only going to continue. Albeit, with Hillary becoming President, many women would say that she only got to that position because of her husband.
Realistically, pretty true.
And second, many don't see her as a true feminist herself for not leaving Bill after such blatant and public deception and infidelity.
Women should band together, but they won't because they fear the caste above them. As you wrote, they've fed into the dogma that has perpetuated their subserviant status.
Excellent post.
Hey Amanda, you have some good points, especially about the crap that we as women have to go through to be taken even vaguely seriously, but I do want to point out a few things that you said that are bothersome to me, and would no doubt be offensive to others. Because I know you, I know where your heart is, but it would be wrong not to point this out. I hope the fact that I'm a pretty hardcore feminist myself, as well as a Barack Obama supporter, will help in the consideration.
Like I said, your points about appearance and the evaluation and status of women in society are pretty dead on, but your points about race and "blacks" have some racist undertones that leave my spider-senses pretty schkweeky. When I read this post, wherever you write "women" what I can tell you mean is "white women." You probably didn't consciously write this way, but that's what ended up happening. Your entry doesn't take into consideration that there are women who are black, and thus in both "categories". Should minority women be expected to choose to side with white people -- people who largely ignore their needs, blame their situations on them, or at best tell them that "there are more important issues" that "affect greater numbers of people"? Why would they choose to side with "women", who are often immediately thought of as "white women", rather than the other members of their families and communities? Why should they be expected to disregard that aspect of their identity? I wouldn't if I was a woman of color. And it's not just about black women. In fact, a majority of the women in this country (in turn, women are the majority of the population) are people of color. Were I Latina, or black, or Native American, I wouldn't want to side with "white women" either. I dislike being part of the group as it is.
As white people, we tend to think of ourselves as not having any race or "culture", or as being the "default". But this is not true; it's a misimpression created by the fact that white people are on the top of the race hierarchy in America, so we have the luxury (yeah the Women's Studies major in me is coming out -- the usual term is "privilege") of being clueless about any race and culture besides our own, which we think of as "normal". That's why I like the blog Stuff White People Like (http://stuffwhitepeoplelike.com), because it points out in a not-so-subtle yet hilarious way that "whiteness" really is a culture after all (something it's easy for me/us to forget).
We, the group called "women", are not primarily divided by things like appearance and bitchy behavior like you suggest, but by this. Your identity is not tied to your gender or race alone, but a combination. I am not only a woman, I am a white woman, and that gives me a combination of status and confinement. I can't get away from that, or pretend like the boost given to me by being white isn't there, much as I'd like to.
You talk about women being united, but the things that are most divisive of the category "woman" is race and class. As a member of the privileged class, it is my duty to recognize that divide, and my responsibility to work to eliminate it, not only because I am the one in the position of relative power, but also because it is my job to hold myself to that standard. I must hold myself to the same standard I expect of guys, with their privilege. It helps me sympathize, a little, with how hard it is to accept that you got a boost on the ladder of life, not through hard work or merit, but from something you can't control.
Anyways, it's important that I tell you. I know you're not the type of person who condones racism, and I figured you would want to know if what you were saying was racist so you would know for next time.
Carry on with your great discussion of how women shouldn't cater to the whims of men or tear each other down, and must promote women's rights. I can get on board with that, yo.
Ruthie- I understand what you're saying, but what I mean to explain was how people do go with people of their race more so than their gender. I agree with what you said about how black women and Latina women classify themselves within their ethnicities before their gender, and that's what upsets me and that's why Hillary lost. I spoke of "women" because I meant all women. You know I'm not racist, as you pointed out, and I'm clearly not, because I don't see people in colors or ethnicities. I do, in fact, see them as men and women. I was talking about how I wish all women would come together and vote for Hillary- to put women first. But I see that people unfortunately put ethnicity first. Color first. And that is what disturbs me.
Post a Comment